Pros and Cons of Living in Gig Harbor [UNCUT]

Ever been stuck behind someone merging onto the highway at 45 miles an hour? Welcome to Gig Harbor. If you’re thinking about moving to Gig Harbor—or wondering what’s going on behind the pretty views and price tags—this is your unfiltered walkthrough. I’m Catt Johnson, and I’m here to give you the pros, the cons, and the things locals are thinking but nobody else is saying!

PRO: It’s Safe | CON: But Don’t Expect Fast Backup

Gig Harbor is one of the safest towns around. You don’t see violent crime here. The biggest crime drama is usually someone’s Amazon package getting dropped at the wrong house.

But here’s the tradeoff: our police department is small. It’s fair to infer there are only one or two officers patrolling at a time. And if you call 911 near the edge of town? You might get routed through Kitsap County dispatch.

If something happens on the north end while an officer’s tied up on Fox Island, you’re waiting.

Pro tip: Save the non-emergency dispatch number in your phone. It won’t replace 911—but it’s a smart backup.

PRO: Local Charm + Real Amenities | CON: Infrastructure’s Falling Behind

Gig Harbor still feels like a real town. Local shops, independent coffee spots, community events—you can thank groups like the Downtown Waterfront Alliance for protecting that vibe.

But don’t think you’ll miss out on convenience. Target, Costco, Chipotle—it’s all here. No need to cross the bridge for every little thing.

The downside? Our roads weren’t built for this much growth. Highway 16 backs up constantly, and the Wollochet onramp? It’s turned into this awkward politeness death trap. People merging at 45 mph isn’t normal. It’s dangerous—and it’s becoming the norm.

PRO: Involved Parents + Homeschool Support | CON: Limited Options Outside Public System

When it comes to schools, the real strength isn’t flashy test scores—it’s the parents. They’re involved. They show up at meetings. They email. They push back when things get stupid. That’s what keeps the system running.

If you homeschool, you’ll find strong support here. Harbor Christian Homeschool and Classical Conversations at Harborview Fellowship are thriving. Homeschooling is up over 40% statewide since 2019—and Gig Harbor is right there with it.

But if you’re looking for private schools? Options are limited. Two private Christian schools exist—and they stop at 8th grade. Lighthouse Christian is working on a high school, but it’s not open yet. Secular private schools? You’re crossing the bridge to Tacoma.

Daycare and preschool are a nightmare too. Waitlists are brutal. If you don’t lock in early, good luck.

PRO: Plenty of Healthcare Choices | CON: Maternity Gaps + Specialist Waitlists

Basic healthcare? Covered. Gig Harbor’s got primary care, urgent care, labs, plus solid alternative options like naturopathy and acupuncture.

Specialists? That’s where it gets tough. Many split time between Gig Harbor and Tacoma, meaning long waitlists. My own son’s been stuck waiting for occupational therapy—and he’s not alone.

Planning to have a baby? Heads up—you’re delivering across the bridge. St. Anthony doesn’t have a maternity ward. Most families go to Tacoma General, about 20 minutes away.

PRO: People Show Up | CON: It Gets… Loud

People in Gig Harbor care. They show up to meetings. They fight for their neighborhoods. They read every ballot initiative—and they don’t just roll over when change is forced on them.

It’s one of the things that keeps this town from falling apart.

But it also means Facebook groups can be a bloodbath. City meetings can turn into shouting matches. Even simple things—like a new roundabout—spark huge debates.

If you want to plug in fast? Become a Precinct Committee Officer (PCO). You’ll meet your neighbors, stay informed, and actually have a say in how Gig Harbor grows.